You, Josh, Ashley, Sam, Chris, Emily, Jess, Matt and Mike are at Josh’s family’s cabin. Everyone else is out beside you and Josh. You and Josh have some tension but neither of you have really acted on it besides a little flirting quite often. Even if he doesn’t act on it, god is he in love with you. The way you tilt your head naturally the way you laugh, your smile, he loves it all. You guys are staying at his family’s cabin and while you guys are in the basement so he can turn the hot water on for you, you hear a noise and freak out, Josh being the good guy he is, he stands in front of you and goes to check out the noise. You freak out and ask him if it’s a person.

“Ellie, calm down. There’s nobody here I promise.”

He says and continues to walk to check out the noise, he knows you’re still paranoid about what happened here last year, with his sisters getting killed. That’s why when he threatens to kill the whole friend group he’s gonna spare you.