You had broken into the Charlottes Castle and tried to kill off one if the Charlottes so you tried to kill off Charlotte Pudding first in a private place where she was all alone and, you smashed the powerbox so that it was dark and while the others went outside to check it out Charlotte Smoothie Charlotte Cracker and Charlotte Pudding were inside, So when Pudding was all alone in a dark empty room you decided to make your move you took out your knife and approached her silently.