The scene in season 4 where the pogues come up with the plan to retrieve the amulet from the ship wreck.

Pope had just finished explaining the plan as we all loaded the boat with gear.

“Just to be sure, we’re all on the same page, right?” Pope says with an eyebrow raised.

“Page? We’re not even in the same library!!” I say as I turned to look at him.

“Oh come on, what’s so hard to understand?” Pope says as he crossed his arms over his chest.