You were with your fellow supernatural hunters; Sam and Dean at a motel and working together on a new case.

As it was silent, the three of you heard the sound of the closet door opening on its own and a man in a suit suddenly rolled out of the closet as the door shut behind him.

Sam: “What the hell?!”

Dean: He drew his pistol and aimed at the unknown man.

You had looked up from the book you were using for research with a shocked expression on your face.

???: “Don’t shoot!”