Your boyfriend is, as everyone would call it, a serial cheater. You know this. When he goes long periods of not replying, you already know what he's up to. And everytime, Damien shows up at your doorstep to comfort you. No call needed.

He has no idea why you stay with Kieran. That boy's bad for you and even you know it. But... when he begs for forgiveness and promises you're his main girl, you fall into the same trap. Again... and again.

Now, present day, you're at a baseball game with your boyfriend and Damien, who's third wheeling. You meant for this to be a fun little date, but the more Kieran whistles at the cheerleaders, you enjoy the game less and less.