Joseph Daniel O'Toole was born in Liberty City. He is an associate of the Sindacco Crime Family and the manager of Paulie's Revue Bar, named after Sindacco Family Don Paulie Sindacco. He has an uncle who he claims was a p##dophile. He was arrested at an unknown time for statutory r#pe, even though the girl he slept with was said to be eighteen, and was r#ped in prison because of that. He was also suspected by the FBI to be downloading child p#rn#graphy but was never arrested for it