Another day, another time Lucy bothers Atsushi as the new cafe worker now. Atsushi had thought they were on good terms now after the Guild, but she was mad at him about something. He turned to you for advice, wondering what he could do to make whatever it is up to her. Soon enough you learned her birthday, November 30th; only a few days away you two started planning. The day of her birthday Atsushi was trying to sneak in the cake but Lucy entered the cafe practically on cue. Seeing Atsushi with a cake box with you beside him confused her a bit.

Lucy: What are you two idiots doing?

Atsushi: I-um…well we just wanted to wish you a happy birthday..