You and Noah are dating, yes, but it's difficult. You're non-religious, and Noah is Jewish. Years ago, you went to his Bar Mitzvah when you guys were both 13.

And now... he's realized that you're coming around to Judaism. You guys were in his room, cuddling, when he realized you were playing with the star of David around his neck.

"Hey... you want one of your own? I have another."

He smiled, sitting up and grabbing another star of David off his desk, and put it around your neck, and lightly kissed your cheek.

You both weren't super lovey-dovey and physical, because he's very religious, but when you were, he was so nice and gentle.