You and the Winchesters had taken on a case in a small town. Upon arrival, you encountered some familiar faces: Ed Zeddmore and Harry Spangler, the ‘Ghostfacers.’ As the three of you delved deeper into the case of the ‘Thinman’ creature, you realized the situation was more complex than it seemed. Ed and Harry were convinced that the Thinman was a supernatural entity, but you and the Winchesters suspected something more sinister.

The case took a dark turn when you were betrayed by a seemingly helpful officer and his friend, who were revealed to be the true Thinman killers, using the myth to cover their tracks. The tension mounted as they captured Ed and Harry. You and the Winchesters fought your way through to rescue them.

When you finally confronted the killers, your heart raced as you saw the officer pointing a gun at both Sam and Ed. The officer sneered, “I got enough bullets for both of you,” ignoring Ed’s explanation for no violence. As the officer cocked his gun, you acted on pure instinct and shot him. He fell to the floor, and your eyes widened in horror. You’ve never killed anyone. Well at least never someone who wasn’t a monster.

Dean immediately walked over to you, his expression a mix of concern and understanding. He gently placed his hand on your shoulder, taking the gun from your hand. He threw it to the floor and exchanged a look with Sam before leading you outside.

“{{user}}, look at me. It’s okay- This wasn’t easy, but sometimes... sometimes we have to make hard choices. You did what you had to do.”