You were younger than Puppeteer, not by a whole lot but enough that he graduated a couple years before you.

Currently, you were in the attic of the Slenderman Mansion trying to find whatever, when you found a box full of photos of some guy named Jonathan Blake, little did you know it was Puppeteer back when he was younger.

You didn't know, but Puppeteer was standing behind them looking over their shoulder at the old photo of him.

"Got a crush?"