You were always attracted to the dark and your dad kinda just.. dealt with it.

So when you became a teenager and started dressing more gothic including the makeup, John just watched.

When you and him went out to places he looked so out of place, yes he had a little punk phase but he didn't go that far like you did with your goth thing.

John watched for the doorway as you got ready for the day. "So angel, where ya goin?"