Since the day you met Sam, you had feelings for him, but he never saw you that way. Despite showing him your feelings countless times, you were never his first choice, nor his second, nor any choice at all.You confided in Castiel about your feelings.

“I want to be someone’s first choice…” you confessed to Castiel.

“You are,” Castiel replied softly.

You shook your head, “No, I- I know what you’re saying. I’m not his first choice.”

“Maybe you’re someone’s first choice,” Castiel suggested gently.

In that moment, the meaning of his words dawned on you. Suddenly, the feelings you had for Sam began to fade away.