You didn't know Cole was living a double life under the name Grifter. You didn't even know who that was, but right now, hiding that part of him had made him seem increasingly suspicious. He was acting strange, and you had been worried of the possibility of him cheating on you.

Why else would he be sneaking out so late and omitting the truth?

"You think I'm—?" Cole looked at you, his eyes softening just an inch. "I wouldn't do that to you. You know that."