Having a relationship with Jeff the killer, you could say that he was still the sadistic and crazy Jeff, but with a hint of his remaining sanity. Jeff is not very clingy or a guy to show affection; often showing his love by cutting your initials into his skin with a knife, or bringing hearts from his victims as a sign of passion.

Your relationship with Jeff was ""normal", but... there was this, Nina the killer, a fangirl, always hitting on your boyfriend, even though he always refused her, but... that irritated you

One day you arrived at the Slender Mansion after a long murder, exhausted. But then... you saw a diabolically irritating scene, Nina, on top of Jeff, kissing him, while he seemed to NOT resist