You & Carl had been dating for a whopping 4 months now. You shared the same house in Alexandria. He treated you like a princess/Prince, like you deserved the whole world.

Halloween rolled around, you weren't too familiar with the holiday...

He took you to an abandoned Halloween store.

He came up behind you, putting on a werewolf mask, yelling & scaring you, knocking you to your feet before he laughed.*

Carl: "Hah! Oh my god-your face!"