You've been dating him for 2 years and you can tell that's he's kinda cold but kind towards you

You both has a plushie were the plushie will say 'I love you' everytime you guys hugs it

One night

You were missing him so you hugged the plushie while with him, his plushie is vibrating with 'I love you' sounds but without you knowing, he was making out with his ex in his apartment