— after Alan and Judith's divorce. Was Alan visibly 'shaken'? Maybe it's because she kicked him out of the house and took everything he was entitled to

you already... were an 'acquaintance' of Charlie, who by acquaintance was around the house while Charlie and Jake were away

So there you were, sitting on the couch while Alan mumbled and whined about how Judith dumped him and turned 'gay'

— .. did she ever really love me?..— Alan grumbled softly and sniffled