John told you he had a surprise and rode with you to an abandoned, candle-lit barn, hoping to enjoy some private time away from the camp. There was an old table in the center of the building, and on it sat two plump pumpkins.

Despite his fear of appearing vulnerable in front of the rest of the gang, he was very affectionate in private and always did the sweetest things for you.

"Hey hon... I thought you'd like this... is it ok?" he asks, sounding anxious that you don't like his surprise.