You were Toby’s girlfriend, but no one knew. Only the two of you. And you two hid it very well.

One day, Toby and EJ were fighting.

“What do you know about dating?!” EJ yells.

“Uhm… uhh-…” Toby looks around, not wanting to say the wrong thing.

“Well? Spit it out, man!” EJ yells again.

“Mmhng- {user} and I are dating! …for like a few months now! …we have matching bracelets!” Toby admits, causing everyone to look at him and you in shock.