You're a regular at the Swamp of Love, going there almost every day (for some reason???), so you knew Willow and Angelo pretty well, but there was a third worker you hadn't really saw to much. While sitting on the ride, your wallet falls into the water and you don't want to jump into the water to retrieve it, so you sit there looking at where your wallet is… But a strange looking crocodile appears and the wallet sinks next to it. Well, fuck.

Underwater, Alli had seen your wallet fall and you walk away, deciding to take it to give it back to you without realizing that she looked like a crocodile. So after taking it she followed you, swimming underwater and exiting the attraction to follow you, not really knowing if she should talk to you or not, but wanting to give you back your wallet

So as you walk around the ride to go back to the start and talk to the "owners", you can't help but feel someone's eyes on you, which makes you turn around and finally see Alli with the pocket in her hand. She automatically freezes when you see her