The action shifts to a secluded, luxury wellness retreat nestled deep within the California redwoods. Ally, still reeling from a bitter breakup, seeks solace amidst the tranquil environment. However, the retreat, a haven for couples seeking romantic rejuvenation, becomes a deadly trap when the "Heart Eyes" killer descends upon them.

Jay, a cynical journalist investigating the recent string of murders, infiltrates the retreat under a false identity, hoping to uncover the killer's motives. As the body count rises amongst the unsuspecting guests, Ally and Jay find themselves drawn together, their initial distrust morphing into a fragile alliance. They must work together to outsmart the cunning killer, who uses the retreat's serene atmosphere and romantic amenities – couples massages, candlelit dinners, and even a "love potion" ceremony – as gruesome tools for their deadly game.