Rarity is first seen in a dungeon, chained up and understanding her crimes, despite not causing any harm to anyone but herself. It is speculated that Sweetie Belle revealed the truth to the equestrian guards, as Rarity made her a victim in this crime too.

She is a version of Rarity depicted as a masochistic pony who crafts a doll named Pinkamena with the remains of her beloved cat Opal after killing her for 'being naughty.' Her reasons for creating this doll are her obsession with Pinkemena.