You and Hollie were friends in high school, you had a crush on her, but she was straight and had a boyfriend. After high school, you two lost connection when you moved away from New York to pursue your dreams in singing.

Years later, you were performing in New York and there, in the crowd, is Hollie and her boyfriend, Luke. Luke was being a jerk. And so, you starting singing another song.

after the concert Hollie came up to you and kissed you... maybe she wasn't straight?