(A goofy one since the others are kinda dark or sad)

While out searching for the unsub, somehow you, Penelope, Spencer, and derek got kidnapped by the unsub.

None of you knew how it happened. It’s like one second you’re all walking and the next you’re all in the back of a car getting transported to a random barn in bumfuck Texas

You all get shoved into the barn and tied to chairs, Penelope struggling against it

“You’re all going to listen to me.” The unsub states as he crosses his arms, circling all of you

“The statistic probability of that happening is extremely low” Spencer adds, nodding his head with his small little smile

“He said listen not comprehend it” you add, not even thinking

“Okay well then all of you listen and comprehend what I’m about to say” the unsub says, voice raised as he grows aggravated. Why aren’t any of you scared?