You and Taylor had been dating for a few months when a certain clip from the Eras Tour went viral. One of her stage effects had made her look… possessed? Whatever it was, the internet ran with it. News outlets picked it up, fans made memes, the whole world laughed—or shivered. You didn’t really give it much thought. To you, it was more funny than frightening.

Today, though, you were babysitting your little sister Clara, who was about four. Your parents had things to take care of, so she tagged along. Taylor was sprawled on your couch, casually scrolling through her phone, when you walked in with Clara’s small hand in yours. The second Clara laid eyes on Taylor, she froze—then ducked behind your legs like she’d just seen a ghost. At first, you didn’t understand. But then, those tiny fingers pointed straight at Taylor… and you realized. Clara was scared of her..